Judging a quilt show is never easy. In fact, it downright crazy hard. There are so many top of the top quilts in the show it can get very overwhelming at first look.
The quilts have been categorized and juried into the show before we even get there to start judging. If you have 2 quilts in the same category one has to be move to another category. Which throws the judges a curveball as we walk by and say, this should be in another category. All this pre work has been done before we the judges arrive.
AQS has a stickers system that is so amazing on how it all works. Many years ago Bonnie Browning went to Japan for AQS and learned all about this respected system of judging. The Japanese think these thing out in detail. This system takes all egos out of the game and makes the cream rise to the top.
Now, hear is the hard truth, your idea of what is best and my idea of what is best may differ on any given day. That is why all shows change judges all the time. The judge’s they pick have quilting knowledge in a verity of techniques and styles. 3 judges all knowledgeable. One maybe is a long arm quilter, one in traditional and home machine and one is more arties-farties with a traditional back ground. It’s a good mixture of skills always. But it still is a little subjective. Because I can’t control the other judges nor can they control me.
How the stickers work. Each judge is given a sheet of sticker in a certain color. We go around the first category and put our stickers on all the quilts that we like, that represent the category and we think personally are worthy, until all our stickers are gone. The number of stickers very in each round and I don’t know how they, AQS, decide that part. As we move around and around the quilts, over and over, looking at everything, we don’t talk to each other.
In next round, you put a sticker on a quilt that already has been sticker-ed in the first round. Now we are down to all the quilts that have 2 rows of stickers on them. It’s a process of limitation. Finely the last round we can talk to each other. And as a group we decide who will be # 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 place. This part can get a little animated and passionate. We share our expertise and it always seems to work. Then from the first place in all the category’s and we have picture of each of those quilts. We then choose the best of show and the best quilts in that category’s. Not necessarily the best in that technique. It the best overall quilt the knock our socks off. We are looking a color, design and workmanship, all of these elements as a whole.
If you are one of those people that has and over whelming drive to keep putting the same quilt in 4-5 shows in one year where one award is not enough for you, that OK, but don’t think we don’t know that? And what is to say there isn’t something more well executed in the next show? So don’t get you panties in a wade or get hurt feeling. Under your name in the quilt books it will always say "award winner" even if you just won 1 ribbon! Funny how that works.
Here is the top of the top quilts in this year’s AQS Syracuse show for 2016. And I will comment on why they won. Because the best part of judging is we get to touch the quilts, lift them up into the light and look at there backs. And they are Spectacular! We never know who made them. Then when we see them hanging in the round at the Winners Circle, we know we picked the right quilts.
Best of Show- JANET STONE! Janet's quilt, Ewe Are My Sunshine,
The detail on this quilt is overwhelming. Beads, trim embroidery.
This is an original design.
Flora Joy of Johnson City, TN, SLEEP, PRAY, SCREAM
Who isn't amazed by Flora's work! but when you can touch it you see so much more going on!
The engineering of this quilt and her technique is mind blowing. On each layer in-between the quilt there are embroidered saying and beads and its just takes your breath away.
HAPPY HALLOWEEN 2, Aki Sakai, Hachiouji, Tokyo, JapanThe detail in this quilt was truly made by a master of hand stitching. She had even made the beads that dangle from its borders. It is made up of 11 little quilts all finished and bound and held together with tinny little orange yo yo's.
The more we looked the more we saw. So well executed and fun to look at!
Very unique design! The hand work on this quilt was spectacular! The subtle changes in the color blew us away and her hand embroidery was perfect.
HOPELESS, Janneke de Vries-Bodzinga, Kollumerzwaag, Friesland, Netherlands
SILK ROAD SAMPLER, Melissa Sobotka, Richardson, TX
I real have no words except Amazing! This is not painted! Each color has been cut out and fused. Great job at shading with fabric and bring this subject matter to the forefront.
SHELLABRATION, Christine Wickert, Penfield, NY
This is all done by hand. I thought the composition was fresh and modern even thou it was a classic design. The rich color change is elegant and each row of clam shell have an alternating pattern design. Beautiful.
These are the top award winners but there was so many award winner in the show it was hard to break it down to these top 7. Congratulation to all in the show. And for those of you that have never entered your beautiful quilts in a show. I say, Stop It. If God has giving you a gift, share it with the rest of us. That's why he gave it to you.